The Texas Longhorns have found themselves at the center of a quarterback controversy as tensions flare between Quinn Ewers and Arch Manning. Head coach Steve Sarkisian’s decision-making has come under fire from alumni and analysts alike, igniting debates about the future of the program.
The Ewers vs. Manning Debate
Quinn Ewers, a former five-star recruit, has been the starting quarterback for Texas, delivering solid performances but also struggling with inconsistency. His 2024 season statistics were respectable, with 3,472 passing yards, 31 touchdowns, and 12 interceptions. However, his occasional lapses in accuracy and decision-making have led to calls for change.
Enter Arch Manning—the highly touted recruit from the legendary Manning family. Despite limited playing time, Manning has impressed in brief appearances, showing poise, accuracy, and a strong football IQ. His 67.8% completion rate, 939 yards, and nine touchdowns in relief duty have only intensified the calls for him to take over the starting role.
Alumni Criticism & Sarkisian’s Decision-Making
The controversy escalated when former Texas quarterback Chris Simms publicly questioned Sarkisian’s commitment to Ewers. Simms suggested that Manning possessed a better arm, decision-making skills, and overall upside. “From everything I know, Arch is the guy. Sark can do more with him—not just because of his mobility but because he’s a better thrower and decision-maker,” Simms remarked.
Sarkisian, however, has remained steadfast in his support of Ewers, reaffirming him as the starter despite mounting pressure. His decision was particularly scrutinized following Texas’ loss to Georgia in the College Football Playoff semifinals, where Ewers struggled against an elite defense. Many believed that Manning should have been given an opportunity to spark the offense.
The Future of Texas’ Quarterback Room
With Ewers’ inconsistency and the immense potential of Manning, Sarkisian faces one of the most challenging decisions of his tenure. Should he stick with Ewers, hoping for further development, or should he hand the reins to Manning and risk alienating a veteran leader?
There are also transfer implications. If Ewers retains the starting job, there is speculation that Manning could explore a transfer opportunity. Conversely, if Manning takes over, Ewers might look to leave Texas for a program where he can finish his college career as a guaranteed starter.
What’s Next for the Longhorns?
The Longhorns are set to enter a pivotal offseason, with both quarterbacks vying for the top spot. Fans, alumni, and analysts will continue to voice their opinions, but ultimately, it is Sarkisian who must make the call. His decision will not only impact the team’s success in 2025 but could also shape Texas football’s trajectory for years to come.
As the Longhorns prepare for their next campaign, the quarterback battle remains the most intriguing storyline in Austin. Whether it’s Ewers or Manning leading the charge, Texas fans are eager to see their team return to national prominence.
Leave a Reply